Madison LeCroy is talking amid speculation that she had an affair with Alex Rodriguez, Jennifer Lopez's partner.

After Thursday's episode of the Bravo Reality series, when LeCroy was accused by some of her friends of having slept with former MLB players, married, rumors surfaced that one of the men in question may have been Rodriguez.

Now, LeCroy is claiming that she and the professional baseball player have communicated over the phone, but denies that they have ever had a physical relationship.

A source familiar with Rodriguez, 45, told PEOPLE: "Alex has never met him."

In an interview with Page Six on Wednesday, LeCroy claimed the couple had "talked on the phone" - phones he called 'innocent' - but said they had never met.